SAFFLORITE


(Co,Ni,Fe)As2,
cobalt arsenide




Safflorite was first recognized locally by Oen et al. (1984) in specimens from the nickel arsenide assemblage, recovered in 1890 during the sinking of the Trotter shaft.  To date it is not known from Sterling Hill.  Inasmuch as the nickel arsenides from Franklin were found but once, in quite limited quantity, and few of those are known to contain safflorite, the species must be regarded as quite rare locally.  A short but accurate description of the mineral was given by Dunn (1995, p. 552), who noted that safflorite is bright white in reflected light and occurs as “tiny 0.1 mm crystals at the outermost fringes of the rammelsbergite-safflorite ends of … nickeline dendrites.”  The safflorite in these areas forms thin crusts of elongated crystals projecting into the calcite gangue enveloping the bulbous ends of the dendrites. Several excellent photographs of such crusts are shown on p. 1063 in King et al. (2021).  Textural details of the overall assemblage are explained under specimen SFL1 below.

Safflorite as a component of the nickel arsenide assemblage was confirmed by X-ray camera methods and electron probe microchemical analysis by Oen et al. (1984), who also reported löllingite (FeAs2) from the same assemblage.  The two minerals have similar optical properties and can be difficult to tell apart by reflected-light microscopy.  To complicate matters, both Oen et al. (1984) and Verbeek and Sutphin (1990) reported löllingite encrusting rammelsbergite from the knobby ends of individual dendrite branches, similar to where safflorite occurs.  However, some of the grains studied by Sutphin from sample SFL1 gave an X-ray pattern matching that of safflorite, confirming its presence in those areas.

The chemical formula for safflorite given above is for the idealized end-member composition.  Wang et al. (2008) note that the formula should instead be expressed as (Co,Ni,Fe)As2 because stabilization of the safflorite structure requires the simultaneous presence of some Ni and Fe substituting for Co.  A microprobe analysis given in Oen et al. (1984) and reprinted in Dunn (1995) shows the presence of 1.8 wt.% Ni and 1.9 wt.% Fe in Trotter mine safflorite.

References

Dunn, P.J. (1995), Franklin and Sterling Hill, New Jersey:  the world’s most magnificent mineral deposits. Privately published in five volumes, 755 pp. [Short description of safflorite on p. 552; chemical analysis of one specimen on p. 549]

King, V.T., King, N.E., Betancourt, P.P., Bostwick, R.C., Chin, Peter, Hecht, T.J., Kuitems, S.M., Moritz, Harold, Nemetz, J.D., Nikischer, A.J., Sanford, Stephen, Van Fleet, J.A., and Verbeek, E.R. (2022), The Mineralogy of Franklin and Ogdensburg, New Jersey—A Photographic Celebration. Privately published, 1400 pp. [Photomicrographs of minute crystals of safflorite on p. 1063; others on p. 900]

Oen, I.S., Dunn, P.J., and Kieft, Cornelis (1984), The nickel arsenide assemblage from Franklin, New Jersey: description and interpretation. Neues Jahrbuch für Mineralogie Abhandlungen, vol. 150, no. 3, p. 259-272. [Detailed description, with a genetic model, of the textural relations and compositions of the various nickel arsenide minerals from the Trotter shaft occurrence at Franklin]

Verbeek, E.R., and Sutphin, H.B., 1990, Breithauptite from the nickel‑arsenide assemblage at Franklin, New Jersey:  The Picking Table (Journal of the Franklin-Ogdensburg Mineralogical Society), vol. 31, no. 1, p. 2-5. [Brief description of safflorite on the bulbous terminations of the arsenide dendrites of the title assemblage]

Yang, Hexiong, Downs, R.T., and Eichler, Carla (2008), Safflorite, (Co,Ni,Fe)As2, isomorphous with marcasite. Acta Crystallographica, vol. 64, part 9, p. i62. [Reports that stabilization of the safflorite structure requires the presence of some Ni and Fe substituting for Co]



Images





Coppery red nickeline partially replaced by white arsenide minerals, including rammelsbergite, pararammelsbergite, and safflorite
Elaine Whetstine
The images of safflorite shown on this page are reflected-light photographs of polished sections taken from the rear of this specimen. As seen here, coppery red nickeline forms dendritic, upward-branching masses, the bulbous ends of which are sheathed and partially replaced by white arsenide minerals, including rammelsbergite, pararammelsbergite, and safflorite. The rounded gray masses at center right of the specimen are cross-sections through some of these white arsenide minerals, near and just above the tips of the nickeline dendrites; in some a central core of nickeline can still be seen. In addition to these minerals, the parent specimen contains white to violet fluorite (upper right and lower left), large grains of black magnetite (left), and coarse-grained white calcite (upper left). This specimen, one of at least four cut from the same mass, is in the collection of Earl R. Verbeek and formerly was no. LA 275 in the collection of Lee Areson (1916-1987).

Identifier: SFL1a
Locality: Trotter mine, Franklin
Specimen size: 9.5 x 7 x 0.7 cm



Coppery red nickeline partially replaced by white arsenide minerals, including rammelsbergite, pararammelsbergite, and safflorite
Hoyt B. Sutphin
A cross-section through the tip of one of the arsenide dendrites from the slabbed specimen shown in photo SFL1a, showing a central mass of rammelsbergite rimmed by outward-projecting crystals of safflorite, the two minerals separated by a zone of minute, dustlike grains that appear dark gray in this image. Note the nearly uniform appearance of the safflorite rim, despite its being composed of numerous intergrown crystals. This is characteristic of the species, which shows only very weak reflection pleochroism in plane-polarized light. This same area viewed under cross-polarized light is shown in photo SFL1e.

Field of view: The horizontal width is approximately 3 mm.


Identifier: SFL1d
Locality: Trotter mine, Franklin
Specimen size: 9.5 x 7 x 0.7 cm



Coppery red nickeline partially replaced by white arsenide minerals, including rammelsbergite, pararammelsbergite, and safflorite
Hoyt B. Sutphin
The same area as in photo SFL1d, but now viewed under cross-polarized light. The safflorite crystals show strong reflection anisotropy in colors from strong blue to brownish yellow, a property that helps to distinguish it from other minerals of similar appearance. The several hair-thin, straight lines cutting across the photo are polishing scratches.

Field of view: The horizontal width is approximately 3 mm.


Identifier: SFL1e
Locality: Trotter mine, Franklin
Specimen size: 9.5 x 7 x 0.7 cm



Coppery red nickeline partially replaced by white arsenide minerals, including rammelsbergite, pararammelsbergite, and safflorite
Hoyt B. Sutphin
The highly jagged margin of this small mass of arsenides is defined by dozens of elongate, well-formed crystals of safflorite projecting outward. As in photos SFL1d and SFL1e, this photomicrograph shows a cross-sectional view though the bulbous tip of one of the dendrite branches in the specimen of photo SFL1a. Plane-polarized light.

Field of view: The horizontal width is approximately 2 mm.


Identifier: SFL1c
Locality: Trotter mine, Franklin
Specimen size: 9.5 x 7 x 0.7 cm